Kids toys and playthings that go the distance

by Debra Dane on April 26, 2012

in Parenting and family life

I have just done yet another playroom declutter. I try to go through the kid’s stuff at least 3-4 times each year to make it easier for them to see and enjoy what they still like or may have stopped noticing amongst the masses of “stuff”.

 

If I could do it all over again the one change I would make to our toy and plaything selections is I would have invested in less items, but higher quality. It can seem daunting when faced with the choice between doll houses ranging in price from $30 to $500. You also never know what items your kids will play with for years and which will be abandoned shortly after purchase. Just because the neighbours have got 6 years out of their trampoline (justifying the $1000 spring-free version) does not mean your own children will use it more than once a month for two years (in which case the $200 version from Target is just fine).

 

So without a crystal ball we make choices for, and with, our kids about what enters the home (and outdoors).

As I cleared a few more piles of toys, puzzles and games I made some notes on what still stands the test of time in our home. This is not an exhaustive list and I have left off arts and crafts (as that is our number one activity here and deserves it’s own post) and outdoor toys and sports equipment.

Top categories of toys & games that have lasted eight years:

Dress ups and accessories: even at 7 and almost 9 years old these get played with regularly. We have everything from character Princess costumes to foreign items bought on holiday to capes and doctor kits and open ended accessories (including decluttered bits from my own wardrobe).

Tip: When they outgrow dress up clothes keep a few smaller items on hand for visitors to your house. Dress ups can be an activity that friends of both genders and all ages including siblings can enjoy together – a great level playing field.

Toy kitchen and add-on sets of accessories: One item I wish we had spent more on upfront. We owned a smaller plastic kitchen that was used from ages 2-5. Seeing it would be an ongoing hit, we sold that and upgraded to a larger wooden kitchen big enough for several kids to play together (still being played with by almost 9 year old). The kitchen is a hit with both genders and has led to endless games of “restaurant”, “Master Chef” competitions, and very extensive outdoor sessions for picnic games.

Tips: Use recycling items to create your own props (ie egg cartons, cleaned out jars). You can create felt food quite easily for gifts or craft sessions with older kids (As a non-crafter I still managed to make fancy cookies and lollipops that have lasted years.) A larger kitchen doubles as storage for the food and accessories.

kids toys that have longevity

Doll house and extension accessories: for additional pieces I highly recommend items from Djeco, Early Learning Centre, and Le Toy Van- all are well made and worth the money, even having a good resale value if you are like me and try to recoup money later on.

Tip: If you have the space a taller doll’s house will have greater longevity as it is easier for 2 or more kids to enjoy it together and use dolls of varying sizes. Even an upcycled bookcase or cardboard creation can make a great doll’s house.

Building toys including:

Blocks – you can never have enough

Marble runs – wooden, plastic, big or small, even made from cardboard tubes

Magnet sets – ball and rod kits for older kids

Lego – a classic that lasts forever (we brought back childhood pieces from my husband’s home recently). Younger kids can be started with bigger block sets like quattro and duplo.

Tip: It can be expensive to build up a collection of lego so always accept offers of hand me down supplies or grab bargain lots on ebay / garage sales as they can be cleaned and used for decades longer.

Games and Puzzles: My personal favourite way to spend time with my kids. There is so much to gain from playing board and card games beyond all the fun we have. It gives us great opportunities for everyone to learn about taking turns, being a gracious winner and handling losing nicely. It has also let us teach the girls never to give up as many games change course suddenly and just as they are feeling defeated they gain ground and realize it’s “anyone’s game.”

Our favourites (we have a big stash) over the years include: Pictureka, Trouble, anything by Orchard Toys for preschoolers, Monopoly Jr, card games like Snap and Memory.

Tip: add to your collection as the kids age so that they stay challenged and interested, but also know they will sometimes revert to simpler games.

Best games for kids

Figures and pretend play sets:

This covers everything from farm sets to plastic or wooden people and animals, generic or characters.

Extension activities are endless as figures can be used for bath play, creating special “worlds” and scenes, involving other toys (especially those listed above in building toys). A great sensory activity my kids love is taking a baking tray, covering it with mounds of shaving cream and then adding in figures to make everything from a polar landscape to a fairy world all while smooshing and writing in the cream.

Tip: There is so much written opinion out there about keeping toys open ended, avoiding commercial merchandise etc. As much as I think simple, non-branded toys are wonderful trust me that most kids will not be inhibited by favourite sets. Barbie and Polly Pocket are just parts in a world created by the children – a world where a panda bear can drive a car and Barbie can fly. My kids are two of the most creative kids I have ever met (most of their hours are spent drawing, writing stories and doing pretend play) and apart from excluding my most hated toy on Earth (Bratz) I have let them explore their own interests which range from Sylvanian families to Littlest Pet shop and My little ponies.

Each of us will have some toys that we stand our ground on and refuse to let in, but mostly I hope you can see that kids will create whatever comes into their minds whether they use Barbie or a roll of toilet paper and a bunch of stuff from the recycling.  My friend, who gave her boys dolls to play with and banned toy guns, still found them naturally making guns out of blocks and sticks. Kids will explore and learn most from pretend play, however it comes to them.

 

What toys have you found to be worth the investment and/or stood the test of time?

 

Find your simple,

Deb

Print Friendly

{ 25 comments… read them below or add one }

Katrina Mansell April 26, 2012 at 7:27 am

Mobilo was definitely worth the investment. Expensive but endless creative opportunity and I know it will be something I hold onto for my grandkids!

Reply

Debra Dane
Twitter:
April 26, 2012 at 5:52 pm

I am sure those grandkids will love playing with them!
Debra Dane recently posted..Learning to bite my tongueMy Profile

Reply

Melissa April 26, 2012 at 7:50 am

This is something I REALLY need to do! My girls are 7 and 3 and I can say that I have never de-cluttered their toys! Actually…that’s a lie…I have all the baby toys in a big plastic tub in the shed and I have just recently collected up all the wooden puzzles, but haven’t done anything with them. I have found that with the 4yr age gap, as Miss 7 is growing out of something, Miss 3 is just starting to use it. De-cluttering is something that I really need to focus on an make a start with. Toys that will stay with us forever and never get passed on or donated are Fisher Price Little People – my girls have hours of fun with these, and a day when all the various buildings (supermarket, house, castle, farm, plane etc) get set up and all the characters get used is a day of harmony in our house, my girls just love them! Barbies is another one. We invested in one of those tall dollhouses you spoke of Deb, and it has been great. It is 3 stories and everything from Bratz dolls to Barbies to Tinkerbell Fairies have had a home in it. Our arts and crafts also get used an awful lot and I do a regular cull of textas that are dryed up or crayons that are too small to use (I keep meaning to melt these pieces down and make bigger ones again but have never got around to it). My girls also love their puzzles and board games, so this is an area we have invested a bit of money in over the years because as you said, they promote development in so many areas and are a great way to spend time with the girls.
Melissa recently posted..Planning….My Profile

Reply

Debra Dane
Twitter:
April 26, 2012 at 5:56 pm

The 4 year gap would make it trickier to declutter immediately after the older one loses interest – our close age gap is one reason though it always feels we have a lot as I have to wait until both outgrow something before it goes so mostly i declutter things that were “misses” or gifts that they never took to or obvious things (like now i am pushing them to let go of puzzles that i know are super easy so we can move on to the more age appropriate ones+, educational games that they are beyond etc
Debra Dane recently posted..How I dropped 150 blogs in an hourMy Profile

Reply

Knitty Mummy April 26, 2012 at 7:51 am

This is such a useful insight into what I should be spending money on. I’ve got a 4 and 2 year old and would never have thought that they will still be playing with their toy kitchen in 5 years time. Thanks so much for writing this
Knitty Mummy recently posted..Create a World reviewMy Profile

Reply

Debra Dane
Twitter:
April 26, 2012 at 5:58 pm

It really does depend on the kids, but mine love the kitchen and it was worth adding on even late in the game
Debra Dane recently posted..How to free up extra time in your weekMy Profile

Reply

Debbie @ Aspiring Mum
Twitter:
April 26, 2012 at 10:11 am

I have found that we are still using the same basic toys (much of the same list as you) for all 4 of our kids. My son has cars & train sets – but all 4 of them use those in other areas of play as well. We also have felt boards which are well-loved. I’m really picky about what I buy as I know that it will generally have to last through the 4 kids. (And anything Bratz is banned in this house!)
Debbie @ Aspiring Mum recently posted..Playing With Abandon.My Profile

Reply

Debra Dane
Twitter:
April 26, 2012 at 5:59 pm

We love felt sets (almost added to the pretend play figure category) and still play with cars and ramps and tramps (they decluttered the character vehicles like Thomas and Dora this round but kept the coolest matchbox cars!)
Debra Dane recently posted..Saying no to say yesMy Profile

Reply

kirsty April 26, 2012 at 12:38 pm

I agree with all of the above and would add in a supermarket and fisher price trio blocks, they are brillant and my kids make so many things with them it is unbelivable.

Reply

Debra Dane
Twitter:
April 26, 2012 at 6:00 pm

Those are great – i often loved seeing toy supermarkets online but they were not around much when the girls were small. My niece has one though and i could see how great it would be.
Debra Dane recently posted..Wishing for a little magic fairy dustMy Profile

Reply

Emily
Twitter:
April 26, 2012 at 1:07 pm

Great post! Thanks for the list. We’ve been looking at kitchens recently and also want one to stand the test of time – glad you agree!
Emily recently posted..Whoever designed our front garden didn’t want the plants to dieMy Profile

Reply

Debra Dane
Twitter:
April 26, 2012 at 6:01 pm

Definitely recommend one big enough for 2-3 kids to stand at! We have had 5-8 kids in the playroom all sharing out the food and preparing dishes etc to serve the adults – makes a huge mess but keeps them all happy for ages!
Debra Dane recently posted..Wishing for a little magic fairy dustMy Profile

Reply

Maxabella April 26, 2012 at 1:53 pm

Exactly the same at our place, Deb. Dress-ups and ‘food’. I’d also add soft toys because these days they make great ‘pupils’ and also pets for the dolls. x

Reply

Debra Dane
Twitter:
April 26, 2012 at 6:03 pm

if you need some soft toys shout out – we have enough for a zoo and pet store – no matter how much we try to declutter no one (including me) agrees on which stuffie or doll can go! xx
Debra Dane recently posted..Grateful for getting my husband backMy Profile

Reply

Amanda Eastment April 26, 2012 at 2:07 pm

Most of our toys/ resources have come from “treasure shop” (Op Shop) purchases. We did up a tall wooden doll house (cost us $10.00 to buy) which gets a lot of play and will definitely still be standing in many years time. We also have the same wooden kitchen and tea sets/ wooden food which all provide hours of fun. The wooden train set and various construction sets have been wonderful as are our costumes, puzzles and ‘Little People’ sets.

Reply

Debra Dane
Twitter:
April 26, 2012 at 6:04 pm

Pretty much sounds like our house! we finally let go of little people sets but for years that was one of our top playthings.
Debra Dane recently posted..Simplify your life week sixteen {Slow down and focus}My Profile

Reply

sannah
Twitter:
April 26, 2012 at 4:10 pm

Lego has been the big ongoing thing in our house. But duplo even moreso. The boys, even now at 7 and 10yrs, seemed to have endless imagination for what the duplo creations would be, and create intricate worlds with it (even though it is pretty chunky – it was all in their imagination).
My girl seems to be going more down the kitchen and dress up path, even though she does enjoy a good light-sabre fight, and one of her favourite figurines is ‘The Doctor’ (Dr Who).
x
sannah recently posted..My bucket was full, so I emptied it a bit..My Profile

Reply

Debra Dane
Twitter:
April 26, 2012 at 6:06 pm

I thought they were too old for duplo and passed it on and i swear they love it at other people’s houses – it is one of those cases of the ages on the box not being a true guide. sometimes the chunky factor is the reason they love it – fast results and not so fiddly
Debra Dane recently posted..Learning to bite my tongueMy Profile

Reply

E April 26, 2012 at 5:27 pm

We have Boy Child (13) and Girl Child (8.5). Things that have lasted for us are:

Fisher Price Little People. Girl got some for her first birthday and plays with them frequently. She was playing with them today.

The tall dollhouse. Everyone has lived in there, Barbies, Little People, Littlest Pet Shop animals etc.

Thomas wooden railway and carriages. Boy probably got some of this aged about 4. Girl Child occasionally plays with it and really likes it.

The Car Mat. One of those mats with roads and buildings on it. Boy was given it for his third birthday. He played with it, they played with it together and she still plays with it occasionally.

Freestanding Basketball hoop. Everyone uses it.

Duplo still gets played with and we have had it since Boy was about 1. We have some Lego which also gets used but I find the Duplo gets more use.
E recently posted..Blogging, community and authenticityMy Profile

Reply

Debra Dane
Twitter:
April 26, 2012 at 6:08 pm

Great list! i do really wish we had gone the tall dollhouse – i do think it is great how many kids cross over traditional gender lines – i was worried people would think my list was “girly” but our male playmates always dive in with the kitchen and the dollhouse and “worlds” too.
Debra Dane recently posted..How I dropped 150 blogs in an hourMy Profile

Reply

Marie April 26, 2012 at 9:23 pm

I had to laugh at this Deb. Bratz is the only toy brand ever to be banned from our house! I cannot stand them! Horrible creatures! Great minds think alike don’t they say :)
Marie recently posted..Of Scrap Spaces and Album PlacesMy Profile

Reply

Bec S April 26, 2012 at 10:29 pm

We bought my daughter a kitchen very similar to yours for her 3rd birthday this year. She hasn’t played with it heaps yet!
We have SO many toys and I find it hard to declutter them- I need time when the kids aren’t home because as soon as it’s designated to go it’s suddenly their favourite.

We bought duplo for Hunter when he was younger and he didn’t do much with it. It was only when he was about 4 he started playing with it – then he really got into lego, so we upgraded to lego and now he is obsessed with lego – will spend hours creating!(He is 5.5). But now Savannah is making great use of the duplo – and we just say that’s her lego – despite it being given to Hunter (and he either doesn’t remember or is happy enough for her to have it).
So for us the duplo/lego has been a hit!

Reply

Lisa April 27, 2012 at 12:00 am

My boys (12, 9, 8) love LEGO, of course. They also love playing with Lincoln Logs, Playmobil, Little People and Thomas (my oldest adored Thomas – he has nearly the complete collection of metal ones from Target (that may or may not have been part of the recall – I could never get rid of them because he loved them so much). They also love action figures of any kind and the Toy Story Army Soldiers. My basement is currently the setting for a massive green army men movement – complete with Lincoln Logs, some LEGO buildings, the big red cardboard “bricks”, the car wash from the Matchbox cars – it is quite the setup.

Reply

Debra Dane
Twitter:
April 27, 2012 at 7:25 am

I had my family bring out a set of tinker toys from the States and lincoln logs were my other dream item from my own childhood (not available in Australia) that I had to let go of. I did not have a lot of toys as a kid but remember both fondly.
Debra Dane recently posted..How I dropped 150 blogs in an hourMy Profile

Reply

MummyOnSuir April 27, 2012 at 6:01 am

Generally speaking I only ever have to throw away broken toys with children from 0-7yrs they just get re-sorted and handed down. The toys that are standing the test of time here are Dressing Up costumes, Fisher Price, Little people mixed with ELC Happy Land play sets (we keep adding more bits each child and now have train, farm, zoo, houses etc etc) I will be sad when the day comes to hand this on but know it’ll entertain for many years more at a toddler group! The cheapest dolls buggy ever which is rarely used as it should be (more of a pick up truck) they have all had rides in it and I marvel that it is standing. Books and Bags, handbags, pretend suitcases etc my lot seem to spend a third of all play time packing in preparation to play..? x
MummyOnSuir recently posted..Happy St George’s Day…My Profile

Reply

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge

Previous post:

Next post: